Search Marketing, Organic or Paid?

search engine box overlay on people searching on their devices
Home » Blog » Search Marketing, Organic or Paid?

Nothing embodies the metaphor of the Tortoise and the Hare better than the relationship between SEM, SEO and PPC. Search engine marketing (SEM) is the practice of developing a market for search traffic to your website through long term organic growth using content marketing and search engine optimization (SEO) and short term Pay Per Click campaigns (PPC). Which one is right for you? In this article we will discuss the relationship between these tactics and how they can combine to an effective search marketing strategy.

Search Engine Marketing (SEM)

Search engine marketing is the overarching concept of developing a stream of inbound search engine traffic to your website. Don’t be fooled by the fact that marketing is included in the phrase though. Search traffic to pages other than sales pages can be just as valuable as the promotion of a product or service on your website. A well written FAQ page on a search optimized website can help current customers find answers to questions in a self service manner (reducing support costs) and can also help generate new leads by showcasing your customer support abilities.

Try not to think of search engine marketing as selling your product or service via search engines. Think of it more as selling the information on a web page to someone searching on Google, and the only way for them to buy is with a click!

There are two ways to a get a click: organically or, alternatively, by paying for one. Let’s look at each a bit further.

Organic Clicks (SEO)

Search engine spiders will naturally crawl your website, index its content and display the content in a search engine results page when relevant to the search. It’s free to create content and get indexed by Google but this oversupply of available search results that everyone wants to be at the top of creates a bit of a popularity contest. It takes time to build up your internet reputation before enough people will start casting votes for you to be at the top of the search results.

search marketing concept graphic

Because of this, many businesses focus almost exclusively on paid advertising. SEO takes time and paid advertising can generate immediate results. There are several reasons this is a mistake though. For one, there is a significant number of internet users that use ad blockers and therefore will never see your ad. Right now the number is between 15-25% but that has been steadily rising, especially among those younger than 45. Research has also shown that a substantial number of people scroll past ads to the organic search results.

The numbers don’t lie and the takeaway is this: effective search marketing campaigns must incorporate SEO and consider the long term impact of willfully ignoring a substantial portion of digital consumers.

Monthly blogging on educational topics that are common customer sales or support questions is one of the best ways to attract organic search engine traffic and grow your organic sales funnel. Businesses should ensure they are maximizing the value of the content created by publishing it on their website and promoting it via social media and email marketing campaigns. This integrated approach increases the chances of success of organic efforts. Content promotion is a great way to earn backlinks and shares which strengthen your website’s ability to rank higher in search results.

Paid Search (PPC)

Organic efforts often take 6-12 months to start generating a stable flow of inbound traffic and for new businesses, or established businesses entering new markets, this timeline can be infeasible to wait for results. Therefore, allocating a portion of search marketing budgets to PPC campaigns is an effective way to stimulate business. $500 a month is a good starting point for a pay per click advertising budget.

There are an overwhelming number of platforms these days to advertise on and they all have various audiences and demographics. An experienced marketing consultant can analyze your specific market characteristics and compare those with platform demographics to develop a plan of attack.

On a more general level you can’t go wrong with Facebook and Google. These two platforms have the largest user bases and are the most developed advertising platforms.

Facebook advertising is going to be a lower converting platform for many businesses, but the cost per click is substantially cheaper than most alternatives which makes it a great place to experiment, collect data, and gain an understanding of what resonates with your digital market so you can take that information and apply it to more expensive, higher converting platforms such as Google or LinkedIn.

Like our insights?
Subscribe to our email list for additional content and promotions for business services.

Search Marketing and Data

One of the greatest things about search marketing campaigns is the data that becomes available from launching one. From and SEO and content marketing perspective it might surprise you what sort of attention you’ll attract when you post an article. Often times you will generate impressions and clicks for keywords you never thought would generate interest when you created the content. This sort of unplanned inbound traffic can help you refine your product and service offerings.

Pay per click campaigns can also be invaluable because they can help you answer questions such as:

  • What offers are resonating with your audience?
  • What are the demographics of your audience?
  • What price points are attracting interest?
  • Are my customers price sensitive or quality focused?
  • Who do they want to do business with? How do we define our company culture?

Split testing paid search campaigns is a fantastic way to get data to help you drive offline and digital improvements to your business. It also becomes markedly cheaper to test out business hypothesis compared to what it was 20 years ago. There are a lot of insights in those click through rates!


Search marketing is a deep topic and is not easy to tackle, but it can be very rewarding. If you can convince strangers to consider your business in 300 words or less with a search query or PPC advertisement then you’re on the right track to growth and scalability.

Search marketing requires a two pronged attack. Effective campaigns will include attention to both SEO, organic content growth, and pay per click campaigns.

Posted in:

Hunter Nelson

Hunter has more than 10 years’ experience in the software industry building and configuring software for companies such as American Express, Black Knight, Homes & Land, Verizon and more. Hunter earned his bachelor’s degree in Information Technology from Florida State University in 2009 and began his career consulting for Accenture out of the New York City office. After accruing significant experience working with Fortune 500 Clients on complex software projects as an analyst, he discovered his love for coding and building software. While practicing the craft he earned an MBA from Florida State in 2017. In 2018 he founded Tortoise and Hare Software to begin providing business value in digital consulting engagements to small and medium sized businesses and helping them along in their journey toward the Fortune 500. See LinkedIn for more.

Leave a Comment

Up Next

Why You Shouldn’t Use Thank You Pages For Conversion Tracking

By Hunter Nelson | December 14, 2020

Tracking conversions is one of the most important things to do as you strive to achieve your marketing goals. In recent years, a growing number of companies are turning to their thank you pages to determine their conversions. While this tracking method is easy to execute, it’s actually one of the worst ways to gauge…

Beginner’s Guide To Measuring Search Engine Performance Metrics

By Hunter Nelson | October 25, 2020

If you’re new to the world of working with an agency on your digital marketing, you may have questions on evaluating whether or not your investment is making any difference. A website is a cornerstone of digital marketing infrastructure, and a well built website will naturally attract some traffic from search engines; known as organic…

Wrong Canonical URL From Yoast Plugin

By Hunter Nelson | September 23, 2020

The other day I was reviewing some indexed pages in Google Search console trying to understand why I was having a drop in rankings and noticed that I had both canoncial URLs and Open Graph tags indexed in Google that were pointing to my local development machines URL. WTF? I knew that the Yoast Plugin…

5+ Essential Google Ads Campaigns For Your Ad Account

By Hunter Nelson | June 21, 2020

Advertising your business on Google Ads is a fantastic way to drive traffic to your website and generate leads for your company. Many companies don’t know where to start when it comes to creating campaigns, or structuring their account in general, so today I wanted to go over a few of the essential Google Ads…

IT Company Digital Marketing Case Study

By Hunter Nelson | April 13, 2020

In today’s post we’re going to be talking about an IT company digital marketing case study. NetTech Consultants is a Jacksonville based IT company or Managed Service Provider as they’re commonly known as in the IT world. Back before coronavirus there was this thing called a “trade show” where large groups of people would get…

Why Is Blogging Important For Business?

By Hunter Nelson | March 18, 2020

If you’ve owned or run a business for any length of time, chances are you’ve checked out a few competitor websites and noticed everyone has the obligatory blog link at the top of their website’s navigation. Maybe you’ve clicked through a few posts, most of which weren’t particularly interesting or helpful, and chances are a…

Passive Lead Gen For Janitorial Supply Company

By Hunter Nelson | December 30, 2019

Southern Cleaning Supply is a janitorial supply company based out of Panama City FL. They provide cleaning supplies and equipment to local businesses, nonprofits, and government organizations in Panama City and surrounding areas. Southern Cleaning Supply has been in business for over 30 years but experienced an ownership change in 2018. Shortly thereafter, new management…

Bid on Branded Keywords

By Hunter Nelson | December 19, 2019

Why are we spending money on branded keyword searches if we’re already ranking at the top of the page? This is a good question that clients often ask when getting started with PPC and one that has a number of compelling reasons to do so. In this post we will cover why you should bid…

Marketing Consultant For Small Business

By Hunter Nelson | October 1, 2019

It can be a tough reality to face for some small business owners, but eventually every business is going to hit a growth ceiling where networking and referrals will no longer be enough to move the needle. Hiring a full time chief marketing officer or other senior in-house resource to launch a marketing department is…

High Bounce Rate? Digital Marketing is a Game of Inches

By Hunter Nelson | September 19, 2019

One of the first metrics people are going to look at when they start toeing the waters of web analytics is their bounce rate. If you’re just getting started on your journey to building an inbound pipeline chances are you’re suffering from high bounce rate and your trying to bring it down. In this article…