Wrong Canonical URL From Yoast Plugin

wrong canonical url from yoast plugin on wordpress
Home » Blog » Wrong Canonical URL From Yoast Plugin
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    The other day I was reviewing some indexed pages in Google Search console trying to understand why I was having a drop in rankings and noticed that I had both canoncial URLs and Open Graph tags indexed in Google that were pointing to my local development machines URL. WTF? I knew that the Yoast Plugin was responsible for outputting this information dynamically so I started to do some digging in how this was happening and why there was the wrong canonical URL from Yoast.

    After much back and forth with my hosting provider and multiple publishes of my website with the issue resurfacing I was able to pinpoint the cause of the issue relating to the recent release of their “indexables” feature in 14.0.

    Yoast Indexables

    For those who don’t know the indexables feature means that now much of the SEO meta data for a given page is stored in a table in the database, the YOURWPPREFIX_yoast_indexable table. This is meant to speed up the process of retrieving SEO meta data and prevent dynamic pulls in PHP from slowing down page load speeds.

    Unfortunately this table is not registered on the $wpdb object. Many hosting providers, including the one leveraged by Tortoise and Hare Software will use a wp search-replace CLI command internally when pushing sites from one environment to another, e.g. staging to production, to update the sites URL from the current domain to the destination domain.

    If you look at the wp search-replace command documentation you’ll see that the base command will only run on tables included in the $wpdb object which does not include the yoast_indexable table! This command would have to be run with an –all-tables flag to include the yoast indexables tables and that may not be feasible for all hosting providers as this can update more than one instance of WordPress if there are multiple instances stored on the same server.

    I’m not sure if this was an oversight or not on the part of the yoast team or if that was intentional. Either way, the problem will likely persist on hosting providers for the time being and in the meantime more than a few sites are likely publishing out bad canonicals and other references to 404’d or private domains.

    Wrong Canonical URL From Yoast Plugin Workaround

    The best and least invasive workaround at this time is for you to reset the yoast indexables from your production environment. This option is much safer than running a search replace command on production.

    Reset Yoast Indexables

    This is the option I recommend for fixing the issue of wrong canonical URLs from yoast. It’s the safest option and works great.

    1. First off install the Yoast Test Helper Plugin
    2. From WP Admin go to tools > Yoast Test
    3. Click on the reset indexables tables & migrations button
    4. Go to the yoast plugin tools by clicking SEO > tools
    5. Click the “start processsing and speed up your site now button”
      increase site speed button yoast indexables

    That’s it your done. Yoast will regenerate the database tables and your canonicals and open graph tags should be working again with the correct domain name in your URL. Please note that you will have to go through this exercise every time you push from a lower environment to production.

    I’m sure the Yoast team is going to be flooded with support requests about this issue and hopefully they will roll out a fix in the coming months that allows the plugin to play nicer with hosting providers. Until then you can use this workaround for the wrong canonical URL from Yoast to repair your SEO on WordPress.

    Update:

    As of Yoast 15.2, this issue still persists.

    Questions, thoughts? Drop a comment below and get the discussion started.

    Posted in: ,
    Tagged: , ,

    Hunter Nelson

    Hunter is the founder and president of Tortoise and Hare Software, a digital marketing agency for B2B technology companies. Hunter has more than 10 years’ experience building web applications and crafting digital strategies for companies ranging from scrappy startups to Fortune 50 household names. When not on the clock, you'll find him spending time with his family and pups, relaxing on the beach, or playing competitive online video games. See LinkedIn for more.

    15 Comments

    1. Rick on November 18, 2020 at 2:10 pm

      Thanks Hunter, worked like a charm. Saved me a lot of time on this!

      • Hunter Nelson on November 18, 2020 at 2:47 pm

        You’re welcome!

    2. Jake on January 25, 2021 at 12:16 pm

      Glad this post popped up. Was seeing the same problem after using search-replace and then of course when I used wp to search for the old dev link in the dB it did not pick it up either. Have used all-tables and reactivated toast plugin

      • Hunter Nelson on January 25, 2021 at 12:19 pm

        Yep, it’s a sneaky issue. I just checked it recently and it still persists in certain cases as of 01/21. I suspect it will be an ongoing battle without a change in direction on Yoast’s end. I saw they recently tried to disable re-indexing on non production environments but that’s not a sufficient fix :-/

    3. Andy Ingham on March 9, 2021 at 3:58 pm

      We encountered this issue as well. Thanks for the helpful post.

      • Hunter Nelson on March 9, 2021 at 4:04 pm

        You’re welcome, glad we could help

    4. Elijah on April 19, 2021 at 7:51 pm

      We’ve also had this issue, but unfortunately our production site has login disabled as a security measure and I can’t login to regenerate the URLs.
      Hopefully this is being addressed/fixed.

      • Hunter Nelson on April 20, 2021 at 1:56 am

        Sorry to hear that. That’s a tricky situation, but I certainly understand the need to restrict access.

    5. Mudassir on May 16, 2021 at 1:26 am

      Hello Nelson, I stumbled upon this post as I encountered the wrong canonical URLs on my blog’s posts with Yoast plugin. I understand that you recommend to use “Yoast test helper”, but I wanted to give a try to “Rank math”, so I installed it and now the issue is resolved.

      I appreciate you put this information on the Internet, otherwise people like us might get panic. Thanks and have a good day.

      • Hunter Nelson on May 16, 2021 at 12:15 pm

        Glad to hear you found an alternative solution that works for you. Switching plugins is a task that might create other problems such as written meta descriptions from Yoast not carrying over to RankMath or lost functionality when moving from Yoast to RankMath. If you are running them both at the same time, some people may also not want to install both of them at the same time for performance reasons, cyber security risks, or maintainability concerns as well. I know the original purpose of the indexable update for Yoast was for performance reasons. RankMath is most likely using dynamic canonicals instead of loading them from an indexed DB table. That may solve the immediate problem, but miss out on the whole reason for Yoast implementing the indexable feature in the first place. I approved your comment here but just want other people to be aware that this may not be the best fix for them and there’s more to it than just “install RankMath problem solved”.

    6. Maulik Dave on September 27, 2021 at 3:24 am

      I have one Issue coming on my site. I have already changed my website name but showing the old website name on google. and many times check not clearly showing sitemap in google and others search engine portal. Please help me how to fix this issuee.

      • Hunter Nelson on September 27, 2021 at 10:17 am

        It takes a few days after making a change for Google to detect changes to your site. You can speed the process up by requesting a manual re-indexing for each page you’re concerned about at the following link: Manual Index. I’m not sure what you mean about the sitemaps.

    7. Carl France on November 2, 2021 at 7:55 am

      Hunter, I found your article as I encountered the wrong canonical URLs within the portfolio on one of our clients’ websites.

      It worked a treat and resolved the issue for me so thank you so much for taking the time to put it together and sharing it with us all.

      • Hunter Nelson on November 2, 2021 at 8:40 am

        Hey Carl, you’re welcome. Glad I could help.

    8. Barny on November 21, 2021 at 3:05 pm

      Hi all. I was use non www then I changed my website to www. I did reset the migrations. When can it apply for this my website? Thanks for your help.

    Leave a Comment





    Table of Contents
      Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

      Free Email Course:
      Launching Your B2B Digital Marketing Program

      Enroll in our free digital lead generation crash course. A 60 day email series with twice a week emails walking through the journey of how to launch your digital marketing program and generate more B2B leads from your website. Unsubscribe at any time.

      Recent Posts
      msp marketing guide to 5 million+ ARR

      MSP Marketing Guide To 5 Million+ ARR

      In this guide we’re going to talk about how you can use MSP marketing to generate enough pipeline to get to 5 million plus in annual recurring revenue. A lot of the things we’ll talk about in this guide can be used in larger and smaller businesses but for the purposes of this guide we’ll…

      multi arm bandit

      Multi Arm Bandits And PPC Machine Learning

      In today’s post, we’re going to be talking about a common PPC machine learning algorithm of which some variant is leveraged in part by many pay per click platforms called a multi arm bandit. We’ll talk about how they compare to simple A/B tests and why understanding the types of algorithms these platforms use is…

      online lead generation tips for msps

      Top Online Lead Generation Tips For MSPs

      According to industry research by a leading managed service provider marketing firm, 94% of MSPs self-reported lead generation as their number one challenge when it comes to growing their MSP. There’s no question that the vast majority of MSPs struggle with lead generation, especially in the earlier years of their business. It makes sense, most…

      Top Content
      sample brand kit

      Branding Your MSP: How To Get Started

      Throughout the process of launching and running Tortoise and Hare Software these past 3-4 years there’s one thing that I’ve gotten consistently good feedback on. The brand! People who aren’t shopping for marketing, and have no relationship to the company will regularly come up to me at trade shows, or comment on my business card,…

      msp paid search campaigns

      The Ultimate Guide To Paid Search On Google Ads For Managed Service Providers

      Generating leads for your MSP can be a challenge. You spend so much time managing employees, making sure customer support tickets are answered, procuring hardware, and defending against cyber threats, there’s hardly time to worry about networking and doing things like posting on social media. However, you’d like to grow faster, and due to some…

      msp seo ultimate guide

      The Ultimate Guide To MSP SEO

      Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is one of the most important ways to attract new business for mid-market managed service providers (MSP). If you look at MSPs that have achieved any sort of meaningful scale and grown to the 10MM ARR mark and beyond, you will almost always see a significant portion of their growth came…

      About Us

      Tortoise and Hare Software is a boutique B2B tech marketing agency. We help companies like MSPs, SaaS providers, cybersecurity firms, and other technology service providers launch their digital marketing programs and generate inbound leads.